The case against the prosecutor
International Criminal Court , Issue 1542
KARIM KHAN: His appointment as prosecutor at the International Criminal Court is welcomed by the government -- but not human rights groups in Africa
BRITISH barrister Karim Khan delighted Boris Johnson’s government last month when, despite the opposition of many human rights groups in Africa, he won the opaque contest to be the next prosecutor of the International Criminal Court in The Hague.

An old mucker of foreign secretary Dominic Raab, Khan’s clinching of the ICC job seemed to Downing Street a rare diplomatic coup in the post-Brexit era. Sweeter still, Britain’s candidate saw off rivals from Ireland, Spain and Italy. None of the candidates on the final shortlist, including Khan, who has previously defended Colonel Gaddafi’s son Saif al-Islam and former Liberian president and warlord Charles Taylor, had much experience as prosecutors, nor had they run an organisation the size of the ICC, with its 900 staffers.

Kenyan kicker
Khan’s arrival may prove a more tangible victory, however, for human rights-lite governments in Africa. Khan, who was not originally on the shortlist, was only added after Kenya said it would lead other African member states in rejecting the other candidates. Uhuru Kenyatta’s government then tried to undermine Ireland’s candidate Fergal Gaynor, who has represented victims of political violence in the former British colony.

Khan has acted for Kenya in a longstanding maritime boundary dispute with Somalia. But the story goes back to 2012, when president Kenyatta and his deputy William Ruto were charged by the ICC with crimes against humanity – orchestrating mass violence after disputed elections. More than 1,200 people were killed; another 300,000 were chased from their homes.

Ruto hired Khan as his chief defence counsel in what turned out to be one of the ICC’s most problematic cases. The ICC dropped charges against Kenyatta in 2014, after witnesses disappeared. Two years later, it declared a mistrial in Ruto’s case. The court also complained of “intolerable political meddling” by the Kenyan authorities, adding that it could reopen the case against Ruto. Three Kenyans were charged with witness tampering.

Crossing a line
More than 20 African legal and human rights organisations wrote to the ICC in January asking it to rule out Khan for the prosecutor’s job, citing his troubled history in the Ruto case. Khan, they argued, crossed a line from Ruto’s lawyer to his spokesman. After the ICC cases ended, he stayed in Nairobi for a celebratory rally at which the jubilant president and deputy declared that no Kenyan would be ever be tried again in a foreign court. Then Khan told Kenya TV that the ICC cases against Kenyatta and Ruto were politically driven and served “external interests”.

Most damning was the view from George Kegoro, head of Kenya’s Human Rights Commission, who fears that few of Africa’s civil society organisations, which have a critical role in ICC investigations and prosecutions, would trust Khan as its prosecutor. That could mean a slow painful death for the troubled court – or no cases in Africa, which would suit the Kenyan government and others in the continent just fine.

More top stories in the latest issue:

Why pre-Budget silence on reform of tax rules for wealthy “non-doms” must have been a big relief for the chancellor’s wife and a former business partner.

The UK Space Agency, which knows a lot about space, is to cede its work on policy and strategy to the business department, which knows a lot less.

Ex-Daily Mirror editor Roy Greenslade’s self-revelation as an IRA sympathiser is no surprise to Eye readers, who knew all about “Roy of the Provos”.

Homeware chain store Wilko is slashing sick pay for staff – even though poor sick pay discourages people from staying home when they get Covid-19.

The catch-up subsidy to schools for private tutoring will taper off steeply over the next few years, raising more questions about whether it is good value.

The government’s crony contract with Public First kept health messaging under political control instead of using techniques recommended by health experts.

To read all the latest Private Eye news, get the latest edition - you can subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale: 17th March 2021
Private Eye Issue 1542
In This Issue
Chancellor Rishi Sunak unveils give-and-take away Fudget… Prince Charmless gives interview to jester – Nursery Times Exclusive… Top IRA man confesses to being undercover editor of national newspaper… ‘He’s barking most of the time… but I stand by him’ – Downing Street Top Dog Dilyn on life with the PM… Is Rachel Johnson’s article about cutting her husband’s hair too long and should it be cut?... Europeans now refuse vaccine they were angry about not getting enough of in the first place… Henry ‘Chips’ Channon: The Diaries, 1917-1938, as told to Craig Brown

Behavioural insight
How the nudgers are feathering their Nesta

African oddity
Andrew ‘Thrasher’ Mitchell’s unlovely chums in Rwanda

Pandemic update
The coming tsunami of Covid lawsuits

Read these stories and much more - only in the magazine. Subscribe here to get delivery direct to your home and never miss an issue!
ONLY £2.00
17th March 2021
Private Eye Issue 1541