media news
Naga v MAGA
BBC complaint , Issue 1506
naga-dan.jpg THE outrageous ruling of the BBC’s executive complaints unit (ECU), now overturned, that Breakfast presenter Naga Munchetty had breached editorial guidelines by saying Trump was being racist when, er, he said something racist must have made particularly uncomfortable reading for BBC News’s £200,000-a-year “editorial director” Kamal Ahmed.

Last year Ahmed released a memoir-cum-state-of-the-nation study, The Life and Times of a Very British Man, which publisher Bloomsbury explicitly billed as inspired by being “raised at a time when being mixed-race meant being told to go home, even when you were born just down the road”.

In interviews plugging the book, Ahmed repeatedly said it was time to “start a conversation about prejudice” – which was precisely what Munchetty and her co-presenter Dan Walker were having before being slapped down.

Then again, since the same editorial guidelines that damned Munchetty make it clear that “the external activities and public comments… of staff, presenters and others who contribute to our output” come under the same strictures as on-air remarks, his own overdue dressing-down from the ECU may be on its way.

Liddle comfort
The Munchetty judgment was not even the only recent occasion when the ECU has proved itself not up to the job: on 20 September it issued a ruling on a complaint that Emily Maitlis had been “sneering and bullying towards Rod Liddle” (yes, really) when he appeared on Newsnight in July, which concluded that her “criticism risked leaving her open to the charge that she had failed to be even-handed”.

However, it failed to specify whether or not she actually had – which is a bit like a judge ruling that a defendant’s behaviour risked leaving him open to a charge of burglary, but declining to decide either way.

More stories in the latest issue:

media news

Five days after BBC D-G Tony Hall offered warm words about streaming services, Fleabag’s Phoebe Waller-Bridge announced a deal with Amazon.

A barnstorming appearance at a TV convention from Ofcom’s outgoing boss Sharon White has made her the favourite to be the next BBC director-general.

The Sun is plugging a book celebrating its stablemate TalkSport, and a memo to staff from Rebekah Brooks suggests readers can expect more promotional guff.

PLUS: Dumb Britain, Ad Nauseam, Anti-Social Media, Luvvies & more.

To read all these stories in full, please buy issue 1506 of Private Eye - you can subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale: 15th October 2019
Private Eye Issue 1506
In This Issue
Anger as PM uses Cox’s name to support Brexit… Fury as will of the people ignored… British holidaymaker speaks of ‘Thomas Cook hell’… 98,713th illegal act in office could lead to Trump’s impeachment… Prince Harry: he’s not ‘a hippy’… Vaping under the spotlight… Saudi Arabia ‘to open up to tourists’… Downton Abbey: the Movie, as told to Craig Brown

Hall to play for
Who’s in line to be the next BBC director-general

‘No deal’ hole
The European Commission’s €11bn dilemma

Sun burns
Shameful tabloid tactics in the Gareth Thomas HIV story

Read these stories and much more - only in the magazine. Subscribe here to get delivery direct to your home and never miss an issue!
ONLY £2.00
15th October 2019
Private Eye Issue 1505