in the back
Call weighting
Samaritans , Issue 1688
samaritans.jpg
BRANCH OUT: Worthing’s Samaritans branch is earmarked for closure despite being in rude health
VOLUNTEERS at the Samaritans have learned the organisation’s HQ will hoover up local assets when it closes 100 branches in the name of efficiency – even where they have been funded through donations and legacies from local supporters.

Insiders estimate the first 12 listening centres earmarked for imminent closure will net around £2m, while the “futureproofing” plans to close half the UK’s 200 branches and their charity shops could take that figure over £20m.

Announcing the first round of cuts, chief executive Julie Bentley told volunteers: “We know that our branches are far more than just ‘buildings’. They are the heart of our volunteer communities, offering vital peer support and holding decades of local history.”

She said the shift to replace branches with regional listening hubs in well-connected areas would increase volunteer numbers available for difficult-to-fill shifts in the early hours.

Tipping point
Until now, volunteers and branch leaders have been afraid to challenge the plans after the charity sacked three directors for speaking out and banned them for life (Eye 1667). With nothing to lose, many are now in open revolt, backed by supporters, MPs and local councillors.

Three former directors emailed all local leaders calling for them to mount bold campaigns against the plans (writing again via private emails when they realised their original messages were “disappearing”).

“The idea that this is all to make the helpline more sustainable doesn’t add up,” they said. “The 12 branches closing will mean an instant reduction in the number of volunteers. A reasonable estimate is that about 400 or 500 volunteers will now leave Sams.”

They also raised “serious concerns” about a remote listening service, due to open in April, warning of the “emotional impact on volunteers when taking deeply distressing calls alone at home, as opposed to being in the safe, supportive environment of a branch office alongside our fellow volunteers”.

Money talks
Critics also point to the central charity’s financial deficits over the past three years, in contrast to the healthier finances of many of the closing branches.

Worthing, one of around 140 self-managing affiliates, has more than £730,000 assets including cash reserves and holdings of £184,000 and freehold ownership of its office, valued at £550,000, one of many across the UK funded through the legacy of a local supporter. More than 8,000 people have signed a petition calling on the charity to keep the branch open.

However, Bentley has privately told local directors resistance is futile because closures are based on location rather than size. Even if they were able to recruit another 150 volunteers, she said, it would not change anything.

Despite being separate registered charities with their own accounts, affiliates are bound by the constitution to wind up “forthwith” if the central board withdraws its recognition, with leftover assets transferred to Samaritans Central Charity. Former members are forbidden from operating under the Samaritans name.

Scotched
The loss will be particularly painful in Scotland. Five offices have been told they are surplus to requirements, meaning there will be no coverage of the Highlands and Islands – which have one of the UK’s highest rates of suicide – north of Inverness.

Volunteers believe another nine are earmarked for closure, which would leave just five remaining. Funds raised from sale of properties, equipment and furnishings, plus all their reserves, would be absorbed into the HQ’s coffers.

The central charity already spends £15.8m of its £24m annual income on staff costs, including £687,000 on executive salaries, far more than the 30 percent maximum the Charity Commission says should go on administration.

“If you paid branch directors minimum wage for the 10 hours they do on average a week for free, it would cost £1.5m, not to mention the 10,000-plus volunteers who put in shifts,” said one former director. “Volunteers are the asset, yet they are being made to feel like a financial burden.”

Another, in northern Scotland, said: “We don’t just answer the national helpline – we go out in all weathers if someone is in imminent danger, we recruit, we train, we raise funds and awareness, we work with police, health services and railway stations. Local knowledge is invaluable and we need resources to maintain those community links.”

More top stories in the latest issue:

LIGHTS OUT
A suitably ignominious end to the saga of the planned 3,500-acre solar farm on land around Blenheim Palace, owned by the Spencer-Churchill family.

CLASS STRUGGLE
A number of teachers ousted from the profession for dishonesty, sexual misconduct or violence have had their eligibility to teach restored.

DIVINE PROTECTION RACKET
The Church of England’s response to the Makin Review into its handling of serial abuser John Smyth QC shows that little has changed.

LEVY LIFTING
Sizewell C nuclear power station is already showing up on consumers’ electricity bills as a specific levy, a decade or more before completion.

DATA DUMPED
The Eye has found another unauthorised giveaway of public assets that inspectors at Tees Valley Combined Authority can look into.

FREQUENT LIAR
Solicitor Andrew Milne’s appeal against his stalking conviction failed in terms that must surely muddy his ongoing lawfare elsewhere.

A BRIDGE TOO FAR
Supported accommodation for older children in care has been catastrophic for many young people who are pushed into it when they are not ready.

ADMISSION IMPOSSIBLE
Pearson’s inability to manage its provision of admissions tests is potentially damaging sixth-formers’ route to university.

GOING FOR A BURTON
Carlsberg Britvic’s plans to close Marston’s Brewery in Burton upon Trent continue the trend of major brewers giving up on cask ale.

To read all these stories in full, please buy issue 1688 of Private Eye - you can subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale: 3rd December 2026
gnitty
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
ONLY IN THE MAGAZINE
Private Eye Issue 1688
In This Issue
Private Eye to be guest-edited by Prince of Wales... World stunned that actions can have consequences... Microsoft outage doesn’t annoy people half as much as they hoped... The word ‘brand’ to rebrand... Turkey Times: Optimism as talks agree to outlaw Christmas... Laura Kuenssberg in threesome shock!... Who will be the next James Bond after Robert Pattinson?... In memoriam, Elon Musk’s Cybertruck... Rise of the Rockstar Chef, as told to Craig Brown

Makin excuses
More blame-dodging at the Church of England

Quango & cash
MD on the NHS’s latest reboot

Trusted brands
A Street of Shame Russell Brand humbug special

Read these stories and much more - only in the magazine. Subscribe here to get delivery direct to your home and never miss an issue!
ONLY £2.99
SUBSCRIBE HERE
NEXT ISSUE ON SALE
3rd December 2026
WHY SUBSCRIBE?
Private Eye Issue 1687
MORE FROM PRIVATE EYE