Batters of import
The Agri Brigade , Issue 1663
batters.jpg
FARMED AND DANGEROUS: Baroness Batters is determined not to be ignored by the government
‘Bio-Waste Spreader' writes… SIX months after being commissioned by the government to carry out a "farm profitability review" (something of an oxymoron, given the dire returns made by most UK farms), former National Farmers' Union (NFU) president and now crossbench life peer Baroness Batters has delivered her findings.

Having sought views from across the farming industry, her 50,000-word document proposes a farm policy "reset" that will focus on encouraging farmers to increase food production. But will the government pay any attention?

There is unfortunately a modern precedent of a government keen to curry favour with farmers by commissioning a senior NFU figure to carry out a review of farm profitability, only then to ignore its findings.

In 2010, the Tory-Lib Dem coalition appointed former NFU chair Richard Macdonald to chair a "farming regulation taskforce" to reduce the burden of bureaucracy on farming. Macdonald's 2011 report recommended that government minimise regulation, focus more on "risk-based assessment" and partner with the industry rather than introduce more red tape.

In 2014, the NFU's Andy Foot requested a list from the Department for Environment and Rural Affairs (Defra) of regulations that had been lifted in the wake of Macdonald's report. Defra sent him details of 180 pieces of legislation but, on close examination, Foot found it difficult to identify the removal of any meaningful rules that would impact livestock farmers.

Bad omens
Will Batters' report fare any better than Macdonald's? The omens aren't good.

When Batters handed her review to Defra at the end of October, she confidently predicted the government would publish her 57 recommendations within two weeks. However, publication has now been delayed to some time "before Christmas".

This has led to speculation that Batters' review contains recommendations the government does not like. Does she suggest, for example, revisions to the government's proposal to impose inheritance tax on farmland that would embarrass chancellor Rachel Reeves, were the report to be published in the lead-up to the budget?

Batters has also said she has stripped "diversification income" out of the UK farm income figures quoted in her report, to highlight how little farmers are earning from producing food. Introducing measures to improve farmgate commodity prices might not suit a government desperately seeking to contain food price inflation.

The B-word
Batters is also likely to have suggested that there be no more post-Brexit trade agreements that disadvantage UK farmers. These agreements require British farmers to adhere to higher production standards than farmers in countries like Australia who will soon have tariff-free access to the UK. But, again, such trade agreements offer cheaper food for UK consumers and reduce inflationary pressures in the economy.

Batters has warned that her report must not be put "on a shelf and do absolutely nothing". But with her review aimed at improving farm profitability, and likely to contain proposals that will lead to higher food prices, that's precisely what's likely to happen to it.

COLUMNISTS
Issue 1663
medicine balls
With MD: "The threat of redundancy can be as bad for your health as redundancy itself, and senior managers at NHS England (NHSE) and the integrated care boards (ICBs) have been living with the threat since March. The Treasury initially refused extra funding for the departures over the NHS's current settlement, meaning the estimated £1bn redundancy costs would have had to be taken from money meant for services. But it has now allowed the NHS to overspend this year…"
signal failures
With Dr B Ching: "The government is determined to sideline ‘blockers' that stand in the way of new housing developments – but one of these ‘blockers' is, er, itself. It takes way too long to build new stations on the government-owned rail network. At least 3,000 homes are planned on brownfield land at Beam Park in east London. In 2015 the Greater London Authority and Barking & Dagenham council earmarked £10m for a station on the adjacent railway…"
eye tv
With Remote Controller: "The annual edition live from Blackpool of Strictly Come Dancing, seen as the point at which the likeliest finalists among the am-pro couples have emerged, started this year with a performance by the stars of the UK touring production of Here & Now: The Steps Musical. With BBC Editorial Policy on high alert at the moment, someone perhaps should have noted that the Steps medley included the band's 1998 Bee Gees cover version, "Tragedy"…"
keeping the lights on
With Old Sparky: "Minuscule energy supplier Tomato Energy went bust this month, propelled into administration by a £1.5m fine from regulator Ofgem for being inadequately capitalised. Along with fellow tiddler Rebel Energy (which ceased trading in April), it caps three years of relative market stability, following a chaotic period in which more than 50 small suppliers and a couple of large ones, notably Bulb, collapsed..."
music and musicians
With Lunchtime O'Boulez: "There was a time when changing jobs from running English National Opera to running the Roundhouse in Camden Town would have looked like a retrograde move. Jenny Mollica has just announced her intention to do just that, which says a lot about ENO's sadly reduced circumstances. Mollica has had the top job at the Coliseum for the past two years, during which time the company has enjoyed the odd moment of glory…"
eye world
Letter from Rio de Janeiro
From Our Own Correspondent: "While the hot air produced by world experts was contributing to rising temperatures at the Amazonian climate conference in Belém, our president, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, was getting heat for the deadliest police raid in Brazil's history. The massacre, which left 121 dead including four police, was the work of Rio's specialist urban combat squad, BOPE – whose logo is a skull with a dagger plunged into it…"
in the money
With Gold Digger: "Announcing the latest sanctions against Russia last month ("a huge blow for Putin's war machine"), chancellor Rachel Reeves also promised: "We will ban imports of oil products refined in third countries from Russian-origin crude oil." But this is likely to prove easier said than done given that Russian oil can be sent via countries which don't sanction it, then sent on in a different form. And those who source oil from questionable origins are nothing if not persistent..."
To read all these columnists and more in full, get the latest edition of Private Eye - you can subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale: 11th December 2025
gnitty
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
ONLY IN THE MAGAZINE
Private Eye Issue 1663
In This Issue
COP30 comes to triumphant end agreeing not to do anything... Daleks refuse to accept apology from chairman... The Daily Troylegraph: Trojans welcome new Greek embassy in heart of city... Nursery Times: Rich leaving in huge numbers... Pete Hegseth reveals new ‘Macho' mission names... The question everyone is asking: Why did Lord Mandelson urinate in the street?... Maily Telegraph: Why the Telegraph is a perfect fit for the Daily Mail... Streeting dismayed as doctors go back to work... Eric Idle's Diary, as told to Craig Brown

Pound of flesh
The Home Office's shady money-saving wheeze

Position of power
Which energy companies are too big to fail?

Paper travails
All change at Reach plc and the Telegraph

Read these stories and much more - only in the magazine. Subscribe here to get delivery direct to your home and never miss an issue!
ONLY £2.99
SUBSCRIBE HERE
NEXT ISSUE ON SALE
11th December 2025
WHY SUBSCRIBE?
Private Eye Issue 1662
ALSO AVAILABLE ONLINE