Private Eye logo
in the back
UK in a right Pickles over the Big Burn
Incinerators, Issue 1384
eric pickles.jpg
ELECTION DILEMMA: Communities secretary Eric Pickles is caught between the pro-business pro-burners and those worried about incinerator emissions
AFTER much prodding, communities secretary Eric Pickles finally made a decision on 6 January over a planned large incinerator in Tory Gloucestershire, supporting the planning inspector’s decision that dismissed concern about the health of those living around the incinerator as fluff. The inspector had decided it was right for Pickles to leave health concerns to the Environment Agency (EA) unless there was evidence to the contrary.

Pickles can no doubt rely on the EA to support a drive to the Big Burn if he needs to, to avoid whopping European penalties on landfill. The EA chair is Sir Philip Dilley, who until April was executive chairman of Arup Group, which designs incinerators. He still serves as a “trustee” at Arup.

Pro-business pro-burners
Another member of the EA board is Gill Weeks, who runs a boutique consultancy working for her former employer Veolia on the disposal of hazardous waste, recording an income of around £17,000 in the latest accounts. Veolia runs several incinerators – sorry, “energy from waste facilities” – across the UK.

Enthusiasm for an incinerator is not matched elsewhere, and Pickles has a dilemma as the election approaches. He is yet to decide on an incinerator in Norfolk, despite receiving the planning inspector’s decision last August. The communities secretary is caught between the pro-business pro-burners and those worried about emissions.

In 2013 the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) decided to withdraw PFI credits, amounting to a £169m subsidy over the 25-year contract, from the Norfolk incinerator. But there was no lack of support for the project elsewhere: the “Green Investment Bank”, run by Vince Cable, agreed to put up £51m, while the other investment came from banks, including the taxpayer-owned Lloyds and RBS.

Infant mortality
Last October Defra also withdrew £115.3m in PFI credits from the proposed Hatfield incinerator in Tory chairman Grant Shapps’s backyard – a further sign of the government’s cold feet over the growing incinerator industry. A recent report from the Eunomia consultancy predicted that, just on current approved projects, by 2020 overcapacity would leave UK incinerators short of 9.5m tonnes of rubbish a year. That would require importing huge amounts of the stuff to maintain Britain’s “Binman of the World” industry.

Meanwhile, a large two-year study by Imperial College on birth defects around incinerators was due to report in March last year but has been delayed; preliminary results are to be published later this year. The study was commissioned to deal with colourful maps produced by Mike Ryan, a former Environment Agency worker, who in the spirit of British pluck had gathered the data himself and published his own maps online. He mapped infant mortality and congenital abnormality at ward level in towns – resulting in large red areas (for high mortality or abnormality) downwind of incinerators.

More top stories in the latest issue:

How some of London’s most valuable properties, owned by the Queen, have been sold via a series of leases to sunny offshore tax havens.

Endurance GB, which governs long-distance horse racing, gets its reward for keeping quiet about scandals linked to the family of wealthy devotee Sheikh Mohammed of Dubai.

The Tutors’ Association may speak up noisily for private academic tutors, but it turns out it’s neither an official regulatory or professional body.

Why millions of people who cash in private pensions will be left seeking advice from a bunch of amateurs under the Pension Wise initiative.

Clinical commissioning groups set up to give GPs control of health budgets offer rich pickings to consultants – often with nothing to show for their services.

As payday lenders are squeezed, ‘rent to own’ firms that sell household goods to low-income families are cashing via high-cost credit.

The government is at last considering taking action over landlords who use fake charity tenants to avoid paying rates on empty properties.

Mediation fails to resolve problems in the village of Botton, where disabled people share homes and work alongside their able-bodied co-workers.

To read all these stories in full, you can buy the latest edition of Private Eye - or subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale:
3rd February 2015.
More From This Issue
A Message
from the New Coalition Academy
more »
A Message
more »
more »
Also Available Online
More From This Issue
Private Eye Issue 1384
private eye Only In The Magazine

Saudi Flogging Row – ‘We’ll Flog Them Anything’ Vows Government… New From Gnome – The Pope Punch Bag… Chilcot Report Found on Mars… Nick Clegg Backs Plan to Reduce Career Suicides… Eye Rebranded as the ‘Coca-Cola Eye’… ‘Je Suis un Charlie’: Prince Charles Latest… Lady Antonia Fraser’s Diary, as told to Craig Brown

And also...

- Cartoon special: Eye cartoonists respond to world events, then and now.
- Censor sensibilities: From India to Ecuador, the crackdown on irreverence and dissent
- Palace coo! The Kensington properties owned by the Queen but leased offshore
For all these stories you can buy the magazine or subscribe here and get delivery direct to your home every fortnight.
Next issue on sale: 3rd February 2015.

Private Eye Issue 1383