Private Eye logo
in the back
Competitive caring
Disabled care, Issue 1380
emma knight.jpg
Emma Knight was horrified to learn that her brother was the subject of an online bidding process
WHAT a shameful state of affairs when some of society’s most vulnerable people are packaged up as a list of care needs and put out to tender. Welcome to the new world of market-driven social care.

Emma Knight was horrified to discover that her brother James (pictured together, below), who was brain-damaged at birth, had become the subject of an online bidding process run by Devon county council after charity Guinness Care and Support decided to close Bystock Court, the residential home in Exeter which has been his home for 28 years.

She was tipped off by a care home owner who identified James from the very personal details – including a full assessment of his mental and physical health, medication, care needs and behaviours – supposedly posted anonymously online under “Mr K, a 45-year-old white British man, with a learning disability”. His and the private details of other vulnerable adults are posted on a “brokerage” site, accessible to care providers, so that they can put in a competitive bid for people they might want for their homes or accommodation. Bidders are advised how much financial support might be expected from the local authority (in James’s case £500 a week) and given a deadline for tender.

Emma subsequently learnt that there was only one “bid” for James – who has a mental age of three and also has autism and epilepsy – and that was totally unsuitable.

A crude exercise to minimise costs
Alerted by the Eye, the Information Commissioner’s Office is now looking to see whether Devon council has breached James’s rights to privacy under the Data Protection Act. But his plight also raises other serious concerns – not least whether what looks like little more than a crude exercise to minimise costs by searching for the most “competitive” (ie cheapest) bids will compromise care and safety.

Nor is Devon the only cash-starved authority to decide to put an individual’s care needs out to tender. The Guardian reported in August that Birmingham and Southend councils were using a similar system. But James’s case also highlights the plight of many disabled people suddenly affected by a spreading rash of closures of charity-run residential homes and communities for the disabled – apparently in favour of “supported living” within the community. Guinness, Home Farm and Scope are among those who are closing around 30 generally highly rated residential homes or centres for those with disabilities.

Miriam Keeble, whose sister Helen was left severely brain-damaged after being starved of oxygen during a botched operation when she was five, told the Eye: “Helen doesn’t just need support, she needs everything done for her. She may now be 33 but has the mental age of an eight-month-old. If you asked her about her wishes she would not answer you, and if you offered her the personal budget for her care, she would eat it. Without 24/7 care my sister would stay where she was left, fill her nappy and eventually starve to death.”

Sudden loss of friends and regular carers
For people like Helen, Scope’s Drummonds Centre in Feering, Essex is ideal – except it’s earmarked for closure. Only six of Helen’s 40 fellow residents or their families have expressed a wish to move a small, supported house. For the others, closure is frightening. The sudden loss of friends and regular carers and the familiarity of “home” is compounded by the lack of alternative suitable accommodation available. Rosa Monckton, who runs Campaign for the Learning Disabled, has described the closures as “cruel and harmful”.

When Helen moved across county borders into Essex to live at Drummond, Suffolk county council (which funds her care) said she would remain on the “moving list” until suitable accommodation which could meet her needs could be found nearer home. That was in 2008. Now Miriam and her parents are desperately back on the hunt, writing to the four nearest county authorities. So far they have been to look at only two potentially suitable places – the only available room in the first was not big enough to take Helen’s specialist supportive wheelchair, and the second has indicated it cannot deal with her profound disabilities.

Local authority-run homes and centres for adults with disabilities are largely things of the past. Now the charity sector is pulling out, that leaves the private sector to fill the care void. As Eye readers are well aware foreign private equity firms have been targeting UK real-estate rich health and social care homes for some time – and, as the collapse of the Southern Cross chain dramatically illustrate, private equity and social care proved a toxic mix.

More top stories in the latest issue:

An Eye investigation reveals the extent to which offshore companies own British land and property.

The big flaw in moves to free pub landlords from the egregious beer tie.

The American company making a mess of the Sellfield clean-up is facing lawsuits over pollution and safety in the US.

School playing fields under threat – on Prince Charles’ Duchy of Cornwall estate.

Once again, canal bosses back big business rather than supporting a beloved book barge.

While shareholders cough up and a few traders face prosecution, those in the boardroom can still sleep soundly.

To read all these stories in full, you can buy the latest edition of Private Eye - or subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale:
9th December 2014.
More From This Issue
Are they related?
more »
All the latest gaffes
more »
Top Stories
more »
Also Available Online
More From This Issue
Private Eye Issue 1380
private eye Only In The Magazine

Nursery Times: Prince Charmless to continue ‘heartfelt interventions’ when king… Sir Cliff to Raid BBC Shock… Why those Christmas songs are patronising and wrong… The Secret Diary of John Major KG, aged 77 3/4… Geldof joins fight against Plebola… Controversial picture of enormous arse provokes debate… Tony Blair’s Diary, as told to Craig Brown

And also...

- Staying Indoors and Staying Put: A letter from Baghdad
- Health Check: The NHS is still paying millions of pounds over the odds on PFI contracts
- PLUS: Child’s prey – Russell Brand’s Trickster Tales
For all these stories you can buy the magazine or subscribe here and get delivery direct to your home every fortnight.
Next issue on sale: 9th December 2014.

Private Eye Issue 1379