Even the most vociferous critic might be left in some doubt about the conviction of Ali Mohmed al-Megrahi, freed from a Scottish jail to die with his family in Libya, and suspect that the Libyan was the victim of the most dreadful miscarriage of justice.
The fact that the wrong man was in the dock was evident to those few independent observers who sat through the entire travesty of a trial in the Netherlands nearly 10 years ago. One of those was Dr Hans Kochler, appointed by the United Nations, who concluded: "There is not one single piece of material evidence linking [Megrahi] to the crime… the guilty verdict appears to be arbitrary, even irrational.”
Flawed and glaringly contradictory evidence
Kochler’s report was a damning indictment of the three Scottish trial judges who sat without a jury. The bulk of their judgment pointed to a not proven verdict – and then they convicted Megrahi anyway.
As Eye readers will know, there were alterations to crucial forensic exhibits supposedly linking Libya and Megrahi to the bomb, for which police and scientists could give no proper explanation; there was a succession of flawed and glaringly contradictory evidence from key witnesses, at least two of whom were paid by the CIA; there was evidence of the striking similarity to the modus operandi of a Syrian-backed Palestinian terrorist cell, operating out of Frankfurt, caught with devices equipped to bring down planes – one of which was missing. And then, of course, there was the crucial “identification” of Megrahi by Tony Gauci, the Maltese shopkeeper who sold the clothes identified as being packed in the suitcase with the bomb. In all his statements and evidence, Gauci only ever says that Megrahi bore a “resemblance” to the man who purchased the clothes – never that he was the man.
The judges performed a number of extraordinary leaps of logic to overcome these and all the other problems with the prosecution case, and it was evident to Dr Kochler even then that “foreign governments and secret governmental agencies”, directly or indirectly, influenced the trial.
More top stories in the latest issue:
The reason Britain’s killer Predator drone has been renamed as the cuddly Protector will remain a secret, thanks to defence secretary Michael Fallon.
Tory MP James Cartlidge comes a cropper ingratiating himself with the chancellor as Philip Hammond is forced to dump his NIC plan.
CITIZENS’ ARRESTED DEVELOPMENT
MPs examine why David Cameron’s National Citizen’s Service is a costly flop and far less effective than voluntary sector groups like, er, the Scouts.
CALLED TO ORDURE
As Westminster crumbles, Gavel Basher hears rival Commons committees go to war over the expensive plans for its repair and restoration.
Brighton and Hove’s Corbynistas leap into action after Riad El-Taher, once jailed for breaching UN sanctions on Iraq, is chucked out of the Labour party
Leaving the EU and the single market will cause expensive problems for Britain’s chemicals industry, hitherto a massive export earner for the UK.
Withdrawing housing support for most 18-21 year olds from April will increase homelessness and could cost more than it saves, say critics.