Flaw covering
Post Office, Issue 1483
post-office.jpg A TRIAL pitting 560 sub-postmasters against the Post Office in the high court last week opened with the remarkable revelation that executives knew of flaws in an IT system that could see dozens of people convicted, but covered them up.

The sub-postmasters are claiming they were variously sacked, sued and in some cases imprisoned over shortfalls in their funds that they say were caused by the Horizon computer system. The Post Office has long responded that the IT is entirely reliable (Eyes passim). In 2015 chief executive Paula Vennells even told a committee of MPs that “we can continue to have confidence in the Horizon system”. Yet internal documents show that the Post Office already knew of serious flaws.

‘Blame Horizon’
Papers from late 2012 show that senior managers discussed discrepancies and mismatches thrown up by Horizon that were at that point “impacting circa 40 branches”. But they reckoned that any admission of the problem could “cause loss of confidence in the system”, have a “potential impact on the ongoing legal cases” and “provide branches ammunition to blame Horizon for future discrepancies”. So – despite the risk of injustice – they kept the matter secret. Thirty people with criminal convictions based on the evidence of the Horizon system still languish in a backlog at the Criminal Cases Review Commission.

In court last week the Post Office’s counsel, David Cavender QC, maintained the Post Office’s unequivocal stance: “What it comes down to is: we say Horizon is reliable and when Horizon says there is a shortfall, there is a shortfall.”

The supposed infallibility of the IT system took a further blow with the appearance in court of a memo from as far back as 2009. A Post Office manager described a visit to a branch and reported: “The balances are a mess (in pre-Horizon times the postmistress virtually achieved a clean balance every week)… she keeps getting promises of attention – but nothing is being done.” The memo then adds in bold: “It is Horizon-related.”

‘Existential threat’
The case, which could ultimately cost the Post Office hundreds of millions of pounds, has profound implications. Cavender speculated that “if [the claimants] were right in the broad thrust of their case, this would represent an existential threat to Post Office’s ability to continue to carry on its business throughout the UK in the way it currently does”. In his view, by placing any responsibility for discrepancies on the Post Office, the sub-postmasters were seeking to turn an arm’s-length business relationship between the two “into some kind of quasi-employment status”.

When it suits the Post Office, the relationship is far more intimate. “Every year,” wrote Vennells in her last annual report, “I am reminded of the dedication and sheer hard work of our postmasters and colleagues, serving our customers day in, day out.” When it comes to addressing their concerns over what they consider false accusations of dishonesty and consequent financial ruin, they’re clearly no longer “our” people.

More top stories in the latest issue:

Gross inconsistencies emerge as Arron Banks’s explains his confusing financial support for the Leave campaign. Time to change accountants, surely!

Overpaid housing chief exec Jeff Fairburn’s departure from Persimmon shouldn’t distract from the crazy amounts paid to some of his fellow toilers.

As the flow of dodgy money into the UK has risen since the financial crisis, so staff numbers at the financial watchdog meant to stem it have actually fallen.

Why the Freedom from Torture NGO is still trying to stop the UK and others from returning asylum seekers to the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

Another top Beijing official – the 158th since 2012 – has been found dead after apparently committing suicide following a visit from the anti-corruption goons.

To read all the latest Private Eye news, get the latest edition - you can subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale: 27th November 2018
Private Eye Issue 1483
In This Issue
Let’s Parlez Franglais: Armistice Jour: Le 100th Anniversaire… US Midterm Elections – Huge Win for No One… Brexiteers Heed Roughly 52% of Jo Johnson’s Words… Outrage as Minister Resigns on Principle… Roald Dahl’s Classic Stories: No 94 Fantastic Mr Führer… ‘I’ll Be Charming When I’m King’ Says Prince Charmless… Kenneth Rose’s Diary, as told to Craig Brown

Isles of Arron
Slicker enters the Banks corporate maze

Paul v Al
The great Dacre v Rusbridger spat rolls on

Empire games
MoD’s about-turn on Commonwealth recruits

Read these stories and much more - only in the magazine. Subscribe here to get delivery direct to your home and never miss an issue!
ONLY £2.00
27th November 2018
Private Eye Issue 1482