Private Eye logo
in the back
Aerotoxic shock for the airline industry
Cabin fumes, Issue 1387
richard westgate.jpg
AIR STRIKE: Former BA pilot Richard Westgate, whose death has prompted a coroner to demand urgent action over toxic fumes in aircraft cabins
LAST week’s decision by the coroner investigating the death of British Airways pilot Richard Westgate to demand urgent action to combat toxic fumes in cabin air means the air industry can no longer ignore a problem the Eye has been reporting for 15 years.

It is highly unusual for a coroner to issue a section 28 order “to prevent future deaths” ahead of an inquest actually being heard, but Stanhope Payne, senior coroner for Dorset, said people regularly exposed to fumes circulating planes faced possible “consequential damage to their health”. He added: “That impairment of health to those controlling aircraft may lead to the death of occupants.”

Neurological and respiratory problems
Airlines, manufacturers and industry watchdogs have consistently denied they have been poisoning pilots, crew and passengers because of a cost-cutting decision to “bleed” air from the engines and then cool it for people to breathe in the cabin, instead of taking in a separate fresh supply. They have consistently relied on government or industry-funded research suggesting no link between cabin air quality and the often neurological and respiratory problems which have in many cases prematurely ended flight careers – and in some cases, it is now alleged, also caused deaths.

In the first official recognition of “aerotoxic syndrome” in this country, Mr Payne said he was satisfied that poisonous organophosphates from engine oils can leak into cabins and can, in a number of susceptible individuals, cause serious damage.

The coroner had of course seen the first case study of a pilot, published in the Journal of Biological Physics and Chemistry, which found that Mr Westgate, who died in 2012, had extensive neurological damage, which had also infiltrated heart muscle tissue, consistent with organophosphate poisoning. It provided a link between the ill health crew had been reporting for years and the noxious fumes from engine oil leaking into cockpits and cabins.

In a corner
BA and the industry watchdog, the Civil Aviation Authority (CAA), now have 56 days to detail their “action plan” to deal with the problem. They are in a corner. Either they comply – a tacit admission they indeed have the problem they have consistently denied; or they have to seek a judicial review of the coroner’s ruling.

Frank Cannon, solicitor for the Westgate family and dozens of other aircrew from a variety of airlines who say they have suffered neurological damage and ill health, told the Eye: “No one is expecting BA to ground their bleed-air aircraft, but if they were compliant to the coroner’s report of concern they should start planning a phasing-out of systems that should be consigned to aviation museums.” In the meantime, he added, the industry could fit filters, adapt older craft with retrofit bleed-free systems and take care of their injured aircrew.

Direct fresh air
Neither BA nor the CAA would say if they were going to challenge the ruling. While BA said “it would be inappropriate to comment further while proceedings are continuing”, the CAA told the Eye: “Airlines are required to report any potential safety incidents, including where fumes or smoke are detected on board an aircraft. Although these incidents are rare, we take all reports seriously and review them to identify any safety issues or trends.”

The good news for travellers is that BA’s parent company, IAG, responsible for aircraft procurement, is gradually replacing some older craft with Boeing’s new 787 Dreamliner, which takes in direct fresh air for the cabin. It now has eight, with a further 34 on order.

More top stories in the latest issue:

Fixers and shady sheikhs with vast sums in secret Swiss HSBC accounts raise awkward questions for the bank… and for the UK government.

As HSBC goes unpunished, the spotlight turns on the cosy jobs merry-go-round between the bank and the most sensitive parts of government.

The leaked HSBC files show how actively the banking system is used to shift and launder dubious fortunes connected with dodgy regimes.

The abject squalor uncovered at a Cornish care home – that just months earlier had been given a clean bill of health by regulators.

Another care home operator goes bust as the busy regulator takes on a new role monitoring the financial viability of private social care providers.

Helped by a private US firm, HMRC wrongly accuses a low-paid single woman of cheating and threatens to stop her £8-a-week tax credit.

Calamity-prone Crapita snaps up the expert body that gives the government scientific advice on food safety and security.

Dissent and division mar the opening months of a “People’s Tribunal” set up to investigate institutional child sex abuse in Britain.

The private boarding college group still claiming to ‘guarantee’ places at top universities for rich overseas youngsters, ten years after being exposed.

To read all these stories in full, you can buy the latest edition of Private Eye - or subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale:
17th March 2015.
More From This Issue
Win a £100 prize
more »
more »
All the latest gaffes
more »
Also Available Online
More From This Issue
Private Eye Issue 1387
private eye Only In The Magazine

Was Ernst Blofeld Radicalised by MI6?... The Jihadi John I Knew – by Everyone… Santa to Move Christmas for 2022… Social Care Scandal as Elderly Lady Has Fall… Me and My Spoon, with Green Party leader Natalie Bennett… Greece: Brussels Hails Historic Agreement to Pretend it has an Historic Agreement… Will Hutton: The Overstate We’re In, as told to Craig Brown

And also...

- Radio silence: The other big media group that sat on the tax avoidance story
- Leak stew: Fixers and shady sheikhs emerge from the HSBC shadows
- Telegraph timeline: Inside story of the once-great paper’s fall from grace
For all these stories you can buy the magazine or subscribe here and get delivery direct to your home every fortnight.
Next issue on sale: 17th March 2015.

Private Eye Issue 1386