Private Eye logo
twitter
twitter
rss
rss
rss
rss
gnitty
hp sauce
May sets her sights on an easy target
Deportation, Issue 1397
may niekerk.jpg
MAY DAZE: Home secretary Theresa May is to appeal against a tribunal decision that Nicole van Niekerk ‘enhances the cultural life of the UK’ and should be allowed to stay in Britain
THE Home Office continues to display as little compassion as it does common sense when it comes to picking easy targets for deportation.

Even though the government wants to be seen to be doing something to reduce net migration, it has always maintained that it “welcomes” highly skilled overseas workers who make a significant contribution to the UK. The van Niekerk family, who came to the UK from South Africa in 2008, have certainly done that.

Benita van Niekerk came under the “Tier 1” points system to take a job as a senior systems analyst. Her husband Eugene is an educational psychologist, and their three children, aged 15 to 19 at the time, were then all still in education. Both parents paid higher-rate income tax and spent more than £160,000 on their children’s education; and in 2013 they were given indefinite leave to remain in the UK – all except their eldest daughter, Nicole.

Extension refused
Because she was over 18, the family had been advised (wrongly, it seems) that instead of coming in as a “dependant” under the highly skilled worker system, she should apply in her own right for a student visa to take up a place to study drama at the University of Essex – even though she was (and still is) “dependent” on her family.

In 2013, extensions to her visa were refused, meaning she could no longer study for a master’s degree or take up work offers; and in June 2014 she was sent a deportation order. Her application to the Home Office for leave to remain on the grounds of her right to a private and family life with her parents and siblings was turned down, even though the stress of being parted from the family was by then taking its toll on her mental health.

In January this year, pending an appeal to a tribunal, she was granted temporary leave to stay, while having to report once a month to a police station – in the words of her father “like a criminal”. This only added to her stress.

‘Worthy member of her community’
Finally, in May, an immigration tribunal ruled in her favour: the judge found that Nicole was and is, because of her health, dependent upon her family and was indeed entitled to a family life. Nicole, who volunteers at a local charity day centre in east London, providing meals and music lessons, and helps organise the local music festival, is, the tribunal judge said, “a worthy member of her community and hence enhances the cultural life of the UK”.

And Theresa May’s response? Almost unbelievably the home secretary is to appeal – and hence waste more taxpayers’ money in her determination to kick Nicole out.

More top stories in the latest issue:

GEORGE’S MERCILESS MEDICINE
Why the chancellor’s justification for cutting financial support for disabled people – to remove disincentives to work, he says – simply doesn’t add up.

WAGES OF SPIN?
Who in the overstretched social care industry will actually pay for the desperately needed new £9 living wage? The answer is: nobody knows.

CALLED TO ORDURE
New peer Lord Bridges is roasted in the Lords over royal security when he tries to sell the idea of flogging Admiralty Arch and turning it into an hotel.

HOUSING NEWS
The plan to force housing organisations to cut rents by 1% for four years may sound good but will mean fewer new homes.

SUNNY OUTLOOK
Former energy and climate change minister Greg Barker steps down as an MP and picks up a clutch of jobs pushing, er, solar power.

NEW BOYS AND GIRLS
Meet Michelle Thomson, the new SNP MP for Edinburgh West, whose pro-business leanings are at odds with some of her firebrand colleagues.


To read all these stories in full, you can buy the latest edition of Private Eye - or subscribe here and have the magazine delivered to your home every fortnight.

Next issue on sale:
4th August 2015.
gnitty
More From This Issue
Crossword
Win a £100 prize
more »
Crossword
In The Back
The latest stories
more »
In The Back
Number
Crunching
more »
Number
Also Available Online
More From This Issue
Private Eye Issue 1397
private eye Only In The Magazine

Royal Family Salutes Edward VIII… Cameron orders Britons to leave UK… Jihadis Split – ‘It’s All Over,’ Says John… Athens Latest: Prometheus Accepts Punitive Terms… Heracles and the 12 Conditions… Cameron Learns from Greece How to Negotiate with EU… That BBC Celeb Letter You Won’t Read… Tim Farron: Me and My Spoon… Marina Warner: What is a story? as told to Craig Brown.

And also...

- Heil Watch: Hurrah for the Mail & Mirror!
- Budget brief: George’s merciless medicine
- PLUS: Phone hacking latest; how Sun supergrasses are rewriting history; the SNP’s business-friendly New Girl; and Remote Controller on wither (geddit?) the BBC
For all these stories you can buy the magazine or subscribe here and get delivery direct to your home every fortnight.
Next issue on sale: 4th August 2015.

Private Eye Issue 1396
gnitty